HRW – 2010 Cuba Report
Events of 2009
The change in government leadership in 2006-when Fidel Castro handed
control to his brother Raul-has had little effect on Cuba's dismal human
rights record. Cuba remains the one country in Latin America that
represses virtually all forms of political dissent. The government
continues to enforce political conformity using criminal prosecutions,
long- and short-term detention, harassment, denial of employment, and
Raul Castro has kept firmly in place and fully active Cuba's repressive
legal and institutional structures. While Cuban law includes broad
statements affirming fundamental rights, it also grants officials
extraordinary authority to penalize individuals who attempt to exercise
them. Article 62 of the constitution explicitly prohibits Cubans from
exercising their basic rights contrary to the "ends of the socialist state."
Political Prisoners, Arbitrary Detentions, and "Dangerousness"
Cubans who dare to criticize the government are subject to draconian
criminal and "pre-criminal" charges. They are exempted from due process
guarantees, such as the right to a defense, and they are denied
meaningful judicial protection because courts are "subordinated" to the
executive and legislative branches.
The Cuban Commission for Human Rights and National Reconciliation
(CCDHRN), a respected local human rights group, in August 2009 issued a
list of 208 prisoners whom it said were incarcerated for political
reasons. The list included 12 peaceful dissidents imprisoned in the
first half of 2009, as well as 25 political prisoners sentenced in 2008.
Of 75 journalists, human rights defenders, and political activists who
were summarily tried and sentenced in a 2003 crackdown, 53 remained
imprisoned as of November 2009.
The government continued to rely on arbitrary detention to harass and
intimidate individuals exercising their fundamental rights. In all of
2007 the CCDHRN documented 325 arbitrary detentions by security forces;
in roughly the first half of 2009 it reported 532 arbitrary detentions.
The detentions are often used to prevent individuals from participating
in meetings or events viewed as critical of the government. Security
officers often offer no charge to justify the detentions-a clear
violation of due process rights-but warn detainees of longer arrests if
they continue to participate in activities deemed critical of the
government. In March 2009 human rights defender Marta Díaz Rondon was
arbitrarily detained when she attempted to visit Jorge Luís García
Pérez, who was staging a hunger strike to call for an end to abuses of
Raul Castro's government has increasingly relied on a "dangerousness"
(estado peligroso) provision of the criminal code that allows the state
to imprison individuals before they have committed a crime, on the
suspicion that they might commit an offense in the future. Scores of
individuals are currently imprisoned for "dangerous" activities
including handing out copies of the Universal Declaration of Human
Rights, staging peaceful marches, writing critical news articles, and
trying to organize independent unions.
Cuba has also applied the "dangerousness" charge to Cubans who are
unemployed or self-employed without authorization. Language in the
provision regards being unemployed as a form of "antisocial behavior,"
and thus worthy of pre-criminal arrest. In a January 2009 campaign
called "Operation Victory," dozens of individuals in eastern Cuba-most
of them youths-were charged with "dangerousness" for not having jobs.
Freedom of Expression
The government maintains a media monopoly on the island, ensuring that
freedom of expression is virtually nonexistent. Although a small number
of independent journalists manage to write articles for foreign websites
or maintain independent blogs, they must publish their work through back
channels-writing from home computers, saving information on memory
sticks, and uploading articles and posts through illegal internet
connections. The risks associated with these activities are
considerable. Moreover, access to information is highly restricted, and
because an hour of internet use costs one-third of Cubans' monthly wages
and is available exclusively in a few government-run centers, only a
tiny fraction of Cubans have the chance to read independently published
articles and blogs.
According to the Committee to Protect Journalists, 22 journalists were
imprisoned in Cuba as of June 2009, including Albert Santiago Du Bouchet
Hernández, who was reportedly sentenced to three years in prison in a
closed, summary trial in May. Cuba ranks second only to China for the
number of journalists in prison.
Human Rights Defenders
Refusing to recognize human rights monitoring as a legitimate activity,
the Cuban government denies legal status to local human rights groups.
The government also employs harassment, beatings, and imprisonment to
punish human rights defenders who attempt to document abuses. In May
2009, after authorities warned him several times that he would be
imprisoned if he did not abandon his work, human rights activist Juan
Luís Rodríguez Desdín was sentenced in a closed, summary trial to two
years for "public disorder."
Travel Restrictions and Family Separation
The Cuban government forbids the country's citizens from leaving or
returning to Cuba without first obtaining official permission, which is
often denied. For example, Juan Juan Almeida García has been denied the
right to leave Cuba to receive medical treatment for a rare degenerative
illness (treatment is not available on the island) since 2003. Almeida
has applied several times per year-including in 2009-for permission to
leave, but all requests have been denied without explanation. His health
has declined considerably as a result of his lack of treatment.
Unauthorized travel can result in criminal prosecution.
The government frequently bars citizens engaged in authorized travel
from taking their children with them overseas, essentially holding the
children hostage to guarantee the parents' return. Given the widespread
fear of forced family separation, these travel restrictions provide the
Cuban government with a powerful tool for punishing defectors and
The government is also clamping down on the movement of citizens within
Cuba, by more aggressively enforcing a 1997 law known as Decree 217.
Designed to limit migration to Havana, the decree requires Cubans to
obtain government permission before moving to the country's capital.
Conditions for prisoners are overcrowded, unhygienic, and unhealthy,
leading to extensive malnutrition and illness. Political prisoners who
criticize the government, refuse to participate in ideological
"reeducation," or engage in hunger strikes and other forms of protest
are routinely subjected to extended solitary confinement, beatings,
restrictions of visits, and the denial of medical care. Prisoners have
no effective complaint mechanism to seek redress, granting prison
authorities total impunity. Cuba remains one of the few countries in the
world to deny the International Committee of the Red Cross access to its
In 2008 the government commuted the death sentences of all prisoners
except three individuals charged with terrorism. Nevertheless, Cuban l
continues to prescribe the death penalty for a broad range of crimes.
Key International Actors
As of November 2009 the Cuban government has yet to ratify the core
international human rights treaties-the International Covenant on Civil
and Political Rights (ICCPR) and the International Covenant on Economic,
Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR)-which it signed in February 2008. In
May 2009 Cuba was reelected to the United Nations Human Rights Council
for a three-year term.
In June the European Union reviewed its "Common Position" on Cuba,
adopted in 1996, which conditions full economic cooperation with Cuba on
the country's transition to a pluralist democracy and respect for human
rights. In its 2009 review the EU said it remains "seriously concerned
about the lack of progress in the situation of human rights in Cuba,"
and elected to maintain the position.
Also in June 2009 the Organization of American States lifted a 1962
resolution suspending Cuba from the group. The OAS conditioned Cuba's
reintegration as a full member on Cuba's engagement in a dialogue with
the group and on its conformity with the commitments, principles, and
practices of the OAS. After the suspension was lifted the Cuban
government publicly stated it had no interest in rejoining the OAS. In
November 2008 Cuba became a full member of the Rio Group of Latin
American and Caribbean countries.
The United States' economic embargo on Cuba, in effect for more than
four decades, continues to impose indiscriminate hardship on the Cuban
people, and has done nothing to improve the situation of human rights in
Cuba. In April 2009 the US government eliminated all limits on travel
and remittances by Cuban Americans to Cuba. Previously, due to
legislation passed in 2004, the US government had only allowed Cuban
Americans to visit the island once every three years, and had capped the
support Cubans could send to relatives at $75 per month. Legislation
introduced in the US Senate and House of Representatives in February
2009 would restore full travel to Cuba for all Americans without
restrictions, but neither bill has yet been brought to a vote.
Cuba | Human Rights Watch (20 January 2010)